|
|
"Less is More" Online
Journalism Researchers Find that Fewer Choices May Lead to Better Recognition of Material
By Katherine Kostiuk
MU News Bureau
Columbia, Mo. (July 12, 2007) -- Researchers at the University of Missouri-Columbia have found that less is more when it comes to online content. In a study that examined responses to pictures viewed online, the researchers found that people were able to pay more attention to pictures selected from a small array of choices than from a large array of choices. These findings may have implications for Internet search engines, advertising and news sites.
"Look at any major news portal, and you may find as many as 50 hyperlinked stories on its front page. The prevalence of this extensive choice online suggests an assumption that people desire extensive options. In our study, however, we found that having more choices is not necessarily better. In fact, it can limit a person's ability to focus on the content," said Kevin Wise, assistant professor of strategic communication in the Missouri School of Journalism.
|
|
Screen shots of six-option and 24-option thumbnail galleries used in study.
|
Wise and Kimberlee (Belcher) Pepple, BJ '04, MA '05, a researcher at Fleishman-Hillard, conducted a study in which participants were asked to select three pictures they would like to examine more closely from an array of thumbnails. In one condition, participants chose from six thumbnail pictures; in another condition, they chose from 24. To determine participants' cardiac orienting responses, the researchers measured participants' heart rates while they viewed the pictures they had selected. An orienting response is an automatic short-term heart rate deceleration that indicates something has captured a person's attention. The researchers found that participants who viewed pictures selected from the array of six showed orienting responses, but those who viewed pictures selected from the array of 24 did not.
After viewing the pictures, participants completed an unrelated distraction task and then were given a picture recognition test. Participants who had selected from the limited array remembered the pictures with 99 percent accuracy, while participants who had selected from the extensive array only remembered the pictures with 89 percent accuracy. Participants also were faster at recognizing the pictures selected from the limited array.
Wise said this shows that recognition of pictures is fastest and most accurate when pictures are selected from limited options. He refers to this phenomenon as the difference between "getting there" and "being there." If a person uses too many mental resources getting to the picture, he or she won't have as many mental resources to use while "being there," when encoding the picture into memory.
"At some point, our mental processing resources become overloaded and cannot efficiently process new information without sacrificing old information. More mental resources were utilized when participants selected from 24 pictures than from six pictures, and this left participants who selected from the 24 pictures with fewer mental resources to devote to encoding the pictures they selected," Wise said. "When the process of 'getting there' requires greater cognitive effort, fewer cognitive resources remain to encode content while 'being there.'"
These results may have implications for presenting content online, especially for search engines and news portals, as well as sites that utilize advertising. Wise said companies might consider presenting fewer picture options online. Similar concepts may also apply to other types of content such as videos and text, but Wise said more research is needed to determine this.
The study, "The Effect of Available Choice on Cognitive Processing of Pictures," has been accepted for publication in the journal Computers in Human Behavior.
Related
|
Nov. 10, 2006: Building a Better Online Community A new University of Missouri-Columbia study may help increase online social interaction if Web designers and operators take note. The study found several characteristics that make people more likely to contribute to online communities, including the presence of a moderator and messages that are interactive and posted at a slow rate. [More]
|
|
|
|
|
Oct. 30, 2006: Research Abilities Develop Practical Career Skills When Roseann Moring, from San Diego, Calif., and Matt Velker, from St. Louis, Mo., enrolled at the Missouri School of Journalism, it wasn't because they were thinking about research. Moring was more intent on getting hands-on training through real-world media outlets such as the Columbia Missourian or Vox magazine, and Velker was focused on working for the convergence journalism media outlets - the Missourian, KOMU and KBIA. [More]
|
|
|
July 7, 2006: Having Control Might Be Good, but It's Not Interesting When people don't have control, they feel uncertain, worried and nervous. However, a recent Missouri School of Journalism study led by Assistant Professor Kevin Wise found that these concepts don't apply to interactive media like the Internet. The study discovered that people respond more positively to images if they don't have control over when the picture is displayed. [More]
|
|
|
|
May 25, 2006: Missouri Journalism Faculty and Students to Present 31 Papers at 2006 ICA Conference in Germany The Missouri School of Journalism will be well represented at this year's International Communication Association (ICA) conference with 31 papers accepted, which were written or collaborated by faculty and student authors from the School and with other professors from the University of Missouri-Columbia and other universities. The 56th annual ICA convention will be held June 19-23 in Dresden, Germany. [More]
|
|
Feb. 6, 2006: New PRIME Lab Web Site to Facilitate Sharing of Media Effects Research With the launch of the new PRIME Lab Web site, faculty, students and other scholars will have an easier way to share data and other information about media effects research. The PRIME (Psychological Research on Information and Media Effects) Lab is equipped to conduct advanced research on how different features of media messages affect attention, emotion and memory. [More]
|
|
Dec. 13, 2005: Research Reveals Slower-Paced, Non-Attack Political Ads Are Most Attention-Getting The most attention-getting and memorable political advertisements are those that use fewer camera angles and scene changes and do not attack other candidates, according to research conducted at the Missouri School of Journalism. Senior Katherine Roehrick and Paul Bolls, her faculty adviser on the project, reviewed more than 70 political ads before selecting 12 to be evaluated by college students of voting age. [More]
|
|
|
|
Sept. 23, 2004: Journalism Graduate Students Receive NNAF Awards Two Missouri School of Journalism graduate students were the first to be designated as National Newspaper Association Foundation Alan Cruikshank Scholars during the organization's 118th annual convention in Denver. Kimberlee Belcher and Shannan Wheaton were on hand at the convention to meet the man in whose name the award was named. [More]
|
|
Sept. 9, 2004: The Missouri School of Journalism Welcomes Five New Faculty Members The Missouri School of Journalism welcomes five new faculty members. Three will join the advertising department as assistant professors: Paul Bolls, Katherine Reed, Maria Len-Ríos, Rick Shaw and Kevin Wise. The more than 90 faculty members at the School of Journalism conduct research in all areas of journalism and strategic communication, have won major teaching awards and serve as leaders in journalism-related organizations. [More]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Dec. 29, 2003: Two Advertising Students Named to AAF Most Promising Minority Students Honor Roll Two Missouri School of Journalism advertising students have been named to the Honor Roll of the American Advertising Federation's Most Promising Minority Students program. Kimberlee Belcher and Bryan Lattimore competed with almost 100 other minority advertising students across the country for this honor. Selection criteria included academic standing, demonstrated interest in the industry, leadership and character and essay content. [More]
|
|
